US Manufacturing 101

Mr. Scott Paul,

You write -

"What Ms. Romer needs to do is explain the phenomenon of Germany’s thriving industrial sector. Despite strong industrial unions, high wages ($48/hour in manufacturing vs. $32/hour in the U.S.), and thick regulations, Germany is able to keep its global share of manufacturing and exports steady while China rises and the U.S. falls."

The secrets that both Japan and Germany use today, are the same secrets that drove the US economy in the 1940's and 1950's. Back then we honored competence in labor and in management. An equally qualified fifth year journeyman produces five times the value of a first year apprentice, while earning only twice the wage.

It is the American short-term focus on cost, without consideration of value that has placed this nation in a myopic love affair with efficiency, while neglecting the competitive forces of effectiveness. Measure the competence of US manufacturing workers to the competence of their counter parts in Japan and Germany. Not only is there a gap, but you may also find that Toyota and Honda, just to name two, have been working hard to train US workers and eliminate it in their US facilities.

Craft unions have long developed the skills of workers in their professions. We don't need to destroy unions, we need to hold them accountable for the skill of the workforce they represent.